Security Considerations

Security is a critical aspect of any protocol that enables tool access and execution. This section outlines key security considerations when implementing and using UTCP.

Authentication

UTCP supports several authentication methods across different provider types:

API Key Authentication

{
  "auth": {
    "auth_type": "api_key",
    "api_key": "YOUR_API_KEY",
    "var_name": "X-API-Key",
    "location": "header"
  }
}

The location field specifies where the API key is placed, and can be header, query, or cookie.

• Best Practice: Store API keys securely and rotate them regularly
• Risk: API keys in configuration files can be exposed if access controls are insufficient
• Mitigation: Use environment variables or secure credential stores rather than hardcoding keys

Basic Authentication

{
  "auth": {
    "auth_type": "basic",
    "username": "user",
    "password": "pass"
  }
}

• Best Practice: Always use HTTPS when using Basic Authentication
• Risk: Credentials are only Base64 encoded, not encrypted
• Mitigation: Use OAuth2 or API keys instead when possible

OAuth2 Authentication

{
  "auth": {
    "auth_type": "oauth2",
    "client_id": "YOUR_CLIENT_ID",
    "client_secret": "YOUR_CLIENT_SECRET",
    "token_url": "https://auth.example.com/token",
    "scope": "read:tools"
  }
}

The scope field is optional and specifies the level of access that the client is requesting.

• Best Practice: Implement proper token refresh and validation
• Risk: Client secrets can be exposed in client-side applications
• Mitigation: Use authorization code flow with PKCE for public clients

Tool Access Control

When exposing tools through UTCP, consider implementing these access controls:

1. Tool-Level Permissions: Define which users/agents can access specific tools
2. Parameter Constraints: Restrict parameter values to prevent abuse
3. Rate Limiting: Implement per-user/per-tool rate limits
4. Usage Quotas: Set maximum usage quotas for tools
5. Audit Logging: Log all tool calls for security monitoring

Provider-Specific Considerations

HTTP Provider

• Always use HTTPS, never HTTP
• Implement proper CORS policies if tools are called from browsers
• Consider using request signing for additional security

CLI Provider

important

CLI providers pose significant security risks as they execute commands on the local system.

• Validate and sanitize all input parameters
• Run commands with the minimum necessary permissions
• Implement allow-lists for permitted commands
• Sandbox execution environments when possible

WebSocket Provider

• Use secure WebSocket (WSS) connections
• Implement message authentication to prevent spoofing
• Consider using per-message signatures for critical operations

Data Protection

1. Data in Transit: Ensure all communications use TLS 1.2+ encryption
2. Data at Rest: Encrypt sensitive configuration data
3. Sensitive Data in Logs: Prevent logging of sensitive parameters
4. PII Handling: Implement proper controls for personal information

Secure Implementation Checklist

• Use HTTPS/WSS for all network communications
• Implement proper authentication for all tool providers
• Validate all input against schemas before processing
• Sanitize inputs to prevent injection attacks
• Implement rate limiting to prevent abuse
• Set appropriate timeouts for all operations
• Log security-relevant events
• Regularly update dependencies
• Implement proper error handling that doesn't leak sensitive information

Common Vulnerabilities to Avoid

Vulnerability	Prevention
Injection Attacks	Validate and sanitize all inputs
Credential Leakage	Use secure credential storage
Excessive Permissions	Follow the principle of least privilege
Man-in-the-Middle	Use certificate validation and pinning
Denial of Service	Implement rate limiting and timeouts
Information Disclosure	Ensure errors don't leak sensitive data

Secure Development Lifecycle

1. Design: Conduct threat modeling during protocol design
2. Implementation: Follow secure coding practices
3. Testing: Perform security testing and code reviews
4. Deployment: Use secure deployment practices
5. Maintenance: Monitor for security issues and update regularly

By following these security considerations, UTCP implementations can minimize risks while enabling powerful tool integrations across various communication protocols.